ITB Nomor 80, Dijepit Raksasa-raksasa Universitas Dunia

Oleh Cardiyan HIS


Kalau penilaian dilakukan secara "apple to apple", ITB terbukti mampu menjadi institut teknologi kelas dunia. Satu-satunya perguruan tinggi dari Indonesia yang masuk 100 Besar Dunia. Dan tentu saja ITB jauh di atas UI dan UGM untuk bidang Teknologi dan Ilmu-ilmu Kebumian. Namun universitas-universitas besar lebih diuntungkan dalam total skor karena diadu dengan institut teknologi yang tidak memiliki fakultas kedokteran, fakultas ilmu-ilmu sosial dan fakultas ilmu-ilmu kemanusiaan.



The Time Higher Education (UK) kembali merilis ranking universitas di dunia. Untuk tahun 2009 ini, dalam total skor ("overall score") ITB kalah jauh dari UI dan UGM. ITB menduduki ranking 351, sementara UI ranking 201 dan UGM ranking 250. Namun bila penilaian dilakukan "apple to apple", karena akan menghasilkan penilaian yang lebih diskriminatif dan lebih mendalam, misalnya untuk bidang Teknologi; ITB nomor 80 (tahun 2008 adalah nomor 90), jelas jauh di atas UI nomor 198 dan UGM nomor 233. Setidaknya ITB akan unggul untuk bidang-bidang yang dimilikinya.

ITB sebagai perguruan tinggi yang sangat spesifik sains dan teknologi, memang akan mengalami kendala sistemik dalam pemeringkatan kalau selalu dibandingkan dengan universitas-universitas seperti UI, UGM dari Indonesia dan universitas-universitas besar lainnya di dunia. Universitas-universitas memiliki "size" (ukuran) yang jauh lebih besar; memiliki fakultas yang lebih banyak; mahasiswa yang lebih banyak, dosen yang lebih banyak (ITB hanya memiliki 1.025 dosen, dimana 775 di antaranya bergelar PhD, sementara UI dan UGM masing-masing memiliki lebih dari 3.500 dosen di mana masing-masing UI memiliki 553 dosen bergelar PhD dan UGM memiliki 625 dosen bergelar PhD). Sedangkan alumni UI dan UGM masing-masing memiliki lebih dari 250.000 alumni, sementara ITB kurang dari 50.000.

Sedangkan bila penilaian dilakukan "apple to apple", ITB akan bisa bersaing bila disandingkan dengan universitas-universitas kelas dunia sekalipun. Tentu saja ITB maksimal hanya akan unggul di bidang-bidang yang terbatas dimilikinya, yang memang menjadi bidang spesifiknya seperti versi Time Higher Education QS (UK) (Lihat: Ranking per Bidang Studi). Namun dilihat dari aspek penilaian berdasarkan kualitas akademis, civitas akademica ITB boleh bangga. Tanya kenapa? Karena ITB unggul dalam penilaian 9.386 "Peer Reviewer" dari berbagai kampus di belahan dunia. Di sini sebetulnya penilaian paling fair tentang kualitas relatif suatu PT (Perguruan Tinggi) dibandingkan dengan PT lainnya. Hal ini seperti dikatakan oleh mantan Rektor Imperial College London (UK), Sir Richard Sykes: “Peer Review is an effective way to evaluate universities. It takes smart people to recognize smart people”.

Sayang juga sebenarnya, ternyata Time HE QS (UK) tidak konsisten dalam menerapkan pengertian Citation Index. Sehingga merugikan ITB dan institut teknologi lainnya dan sangat menguntungkan universitas-universitas besar. Cara penghitungan mereka Cited Article dan Time Cited Article dijumlahkan begitu saja tidak dibagi dengan jumlah populasi dosen. Mereka tidak membuat dalam bentuk "Citation Index" yang akan lebih mencerminkan kinerja dosen sebuah PT karena jumlah karya dan jumlah kutipannya dibagi jumlah populasi dosen.

Padahal disamping ada penilaian "Academic Peer Review" (bobot 40%) juga ada penilaian lainnya. Yakni kriteria "Employer Review" (10%), "Faculty Student Ratio" (20%), "Citation per Faculty"(20%), "International Faculty" (5%), "International Students" (5%). Otomatis ITB dan institut sejenis dirugikan dua kali. Pertama, oleh kriteria lemah The Time HE (UK) dalam penerapan Citation Index. Kedua, ITB dan institut sejenis tidak memperoleh skor sama sekali karena memang tidak memiliki fakultas-fakultas kedokteran dan ilmu hayati, fakultas ilmu-ilmu sosial dan fakultas ilmu-ilmu kemanusiaan. Sehingga jelas ini akan berpengaruh dalam penjumlahan skor keseluruhan ("Overall score"). Itulah sebetulnya kalau mau ditelusuri lebih jauh mengapa UI dan UGM serta universitas-universitas besar lainnya sangat diuntungkan dengan fakta ini.

Coba kita lihat perbandingan dimana masing-masing PT di Indonesia unggul berdasarkan masing-masing bidangnya versi Time Higher Education QS (UK) untuk tahun 2009:

BIDANG STUDI: TECHNOLOGY

80 BANDUNG Institute of Technology (ITB)
INDONESIA
81= Technical University of DENMARK
Denmark
81= POHANG University of Science And Technol...
Korea, South

83 University of Wisconsin-madison
United States

84= Ecole Normale Superieure, PARIS
France

84= National TSING HUA University
Taiwan
86 FUDAN University
China
87= University of PENNSYLVANIA
United States

87= University of CALGARY
Canada

89= University of STUTTGART
Germany

89= Mcmaster University
Canada

91 The HONG KONG Polytechnic University
Hong Kong

92 City University of Hong Kong
Hong Kong

93 University of BIRMINGHAM
United Kingdom

94 HELSINKI University of Technology (TKK)
Finland

95 PENNSYLVANIA STATE University
United States

96 University of WASHINGTON
United States

97 Rmit University
Australia

98= University of BRISTOL
United Kingdom

98= BROWN University
United States

98= NAGOYA University
Japan

101 University of MARYLAND, College Park
United States

102 National Technical University of ATHENS
Greece
103 University of TWENTE
Netherlands

104= WASEDA University
Japan

104= QUEENSLAND University of Technology
Australia

106 NORTHWESTERN University
United States

107 University of SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
United States

108= ISTANBUL Technical University
Turkey
108= ZHEJIANG University
China
110= University of CANTERBURY
New Zealand

110= TEL AVIV University
Israel
112 University of TEHRAN
Iran
113= Politecnico Di TORINO
Italy

113= University of LEEDS
United Kingdom

113= University of CHICAGO
United States

116 University Pierre and Marie Curie - PARI...
France

117 Université De Montréal
Canada

118 University of SHEFFIELD
United Kingdom

119 Technische Universität DARMSTADT
Germany

120 University of CALIFORNIA, Davis
United States

121 Sapienza University of Rome
Italy

122= TRINITY College Dublin
Ireland
122= LUND University
Sweden

124 Catholic University of LOUVAIN (UCL)
Belgium

125 University of NOTTINGHAM
United Kingdom

126 University of AMSTERDAM
Netherlands

127 University of ADELAIDE
Australia

128 University of São Paulo
Brazil
129= University of Technology, SYDNEY
Australia

129= BILKENT University
Turkey
131 University of WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Australia

132 Université Joseph-fourier, GRENOBLE I
France

133 University of GHENT
Belgium

134= University of BOLOGNA
Italy

134= Federal University of Rio De Janeiro
Brazil
136= RICE University
United States

136= QUEEN'S University
Canada

138 DUKE University
United States

139= University of CALIFORNIA, Irvine
United States

139= BOSTON University
United States

139= YONSEI University
Korea, South

139= NORWEGIAN University of Science And Tech...
Norway

143= LOMONOSOV MOSCOW State University
Russia
143= National TAIWAN University of Science An...
Taiwan
145= University of MINNESOTA
United States

145= SHARIF University of Technology
Iran
147 University of BARCELONA
Spain

148 OHIO STATE University
United States

149= ARIZONA STATE University
United States

149= SIMON FRASER University
Canada

149= University of WARWICK
United Kingdom

152= University of GLASGOW
United Kingdom

152= KING'S College London
United Kingdom

154 University of TSUKUBA
Japan

155= University of CAMPINAS (unicamp)
Brazil
155= KOREA University
Korea, South

155= University of PISA
Italy

155= University of MASSACHUSETTS, Amherst
United States

159 NANJING University
China
160= National CHENG KUNG University
Taiwan
160= National Autonomous University of Mexico...
Mexico
162= UPPSALA University
Sweden

162= Hebrew University of JERUSALEM
Israel
164= LINKOPING University
Sweden

164= University of ARIZONA
United States

166= Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati ...
India
166= National CHIAO TUNG University
Taiwan
168 UTRECHT University
Netherlands

169 WARSAW University of Technology
Poland
170 University of HELSINKI
Finland

171= CZECH TECHNICAL University In Prague
Czech Republic
171= University of Colorado At BOULDER
United States

171= CRANFIELD University
United Kingdom

171= University of OTTAWA
Canada

175 CASE WESTERN RESERVE University
United States

176 KYUSHU University
Japan

177 XI'AN JIAOTONG University
China
178 University of BATH
United Kingdom

179= Universidad Politecnica De VALENCIA
Spain

179= Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee (...
India
179= TONGJI University
China
182= University College DUBLIN
Ireland
182= TOKYO University of Science (tus)
Japan

182= AARHUS University
Denmark
182= University of OSLO
Norway

186= KOBE University
Japan

186= Ecole Nationale Des Ponts Et Chaussees
France

188= VU University AMSTERDAM
Netherlands

188= University of VIENNA
Austria
188= University of FLORIDA
United States

191= KEIO University
Japan

191= University of NEWCASTLE
Australia

193= University of LIVERPOOL
United Kingdom

193= CAIRO University
Egypt
195= Saint-petersburg State University
Russia
195= Technische Universität DRESDEN
Germany

195= CURTIN University of Technology
Australia

198= RUTGERS, The State University of New Jer...
United States

198= University of INDONESIA
INDONESIA
198= University of YORK
United Kingdom

201= Tecnologico De MONTERREY At MONTERREY (i...
Mexico
201= University of MALAYA (UM)
Malaysia

201= Free University of Brussels
Belgium

204= Universidad De CHILE
Chile
204= University of ZURICH
Switzerland

206 LOUGHBOROUGH University
United Kingdom

207= University of WOLLONGONG
Australia

207= BEN GURION University of The Negev
Israel
209 KING FAHD University of Petroleum & Mine...
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
210= University of STRATHCLYDE
United Kingdom

210= University of BUENOS AIRES
Argentina
210= The University of WESTERN ONTARIO
Canada

213= University of Toulouse Iii Paul Sabatier...
France

213= ILLINOIS Institute of Technology
United States

215 Autonomous University of BARCELONA
Spain

216 CARDIFF University
United Kingdom

217 University of CAPE TOWN
South Africa
218 University of PITTSBURGH
United States

219= Aristotle University of THESSALONIKI
Greece
219= University of NORTH CAROLINA, Chapel Hil...
United States

219= CONCORDIA University
Canada

222= IOWA STATE University
United States

222= University of SURREY
United Kingdom

222= LAVAL University
Canada

225 Free University of BERLIN
Germany

226 University of DELAWARE
United States

227= University of DELHI
India
227= MICHIGAN STATE University
United States

227= KING SAUD University
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
230= PUSAN National University
Korea, South

230= University of COIMBRA
Portugal

230= Universität HAMBURG
Germany

233= NORTH CAROLINA STATE University
United States

233= HOKKAIDO University
Japan

233= Universitas GADJAH MADA
INDONESIA




BIDANG STUDI: NATURAL SCIENCES

153 BANDUNG Institute of Technology (itb)
INDONESIA
154 NOVOSIBIRSK STATE University
Russia
155 University of KARLSRUHE
Germany

156 EINDHOVEN University of Technology
Netherlands

157= RICE University
United States

157= Université Paris SORBONNE (paris Iv)
France

157= YONSEI University
Korea, South

160 University of CAMPINAS (unicamp)
Brazil
161 University of FLORIDA
United States

162 University of BIRMINGHAM
United Kingdom

163 University of WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Australia

164 University of Colorado At BOULDER
United States

165 QUEEN'S University
Canada

166 University of GHENT
Belgium

167 TOKYO University of Science (tus)
Japan

168= Università Degli Studi Di ROMA Tor Verg...
Italy

168= Universität HAMBURG
Germany

170 University of NORTH CAROLINA, Chapel Hil...
United States

171= University of ARIZONA
United States

171= University of BASEL
Switzerland

171= University of LEEDS
United Kingdom

174 University of MINNESOTA
United States

175 Politecnico Di MILANO
Italy

176 University of The PHILIPPINES
Philippines
177 Indian Institute of Technology Madras (i...
India
178 Johannes Gutenberg Universität MAINZ
Germany

179= University of CALGARY
Canada

179= University of CALIFORNIA, Irvine
United States

179= SIMON FRASER University
Canada

179= University of CAPE TOWN
South Africa
183= ZHEJIANG University
China
183= University of TEHRAN
Iran
183= University of Fribourg
Germany

186 Universitat De VALENCIA
Spain

187 HELSINKI University of Technology (TKK)
Finland

188 University of NOTTINGHAM
United Kingdom

189= University of DELHI
India
189= QUEENSLAND University of Technology
Australia

191= QUEEN MARY, University of London
United Kingdom

191= KOREA University
Korea, South

193= University of Toulouse Iii Paul Sabatier...
France

193= MICHIGAN STATE University
United States

195= University of GRONINGEN
Netherlands

195= University of STUTTGART
Germany

197 University of TRIESTE
Italy

198= EÖtvÖs LorÁnd University
Hungary
198= Universitas GADJAH MADA
INDONESIA
200 DALHOUSIE University
Canada

201= Universität BIELEFELD
Germany

201= VU University AMSTERDAM
Netherlands

203 University College DUBLIN
Ireland
204= University of TWENTE
Netherlands

204= Eberhard Karls University Tuebingen
Germany

206 University of OTAGO
New Zealand

207 Technical University of DENMARK
Denmark
208 University of OTTAWA
Canada

209 University of BUENOS AIRES
Argentina
210= University of CALCUTTA
India
210= University of SHEFFIELD
United Kingdom

212= University Montpellier 2 - Sciences And ...
France

212= Universidad De CHILE
Chile
212= City University of Hong Kong
Hong Kong

212= University of TRENTO
Italy

216 University of LIVERPOOL
United Kingdom

217 BEN GURION University of The Negev
Israel
218= University of CANTERBURY
New Zealand

218= University of GOTHENBURG
Sweden

220 University of BATH
United Kingdom

221= ISTANBUL Technical University
Turkey
221= Universität LEIPZIG
Germany

223= Karl-franzens-universitaet GRAZ
Austria
223= University College CORK
Ireland
223= WAGENINGEN University
Netherlands

223= University of KARACHI
Pakistan
227= Johannes Kepler University LINZ
Austria
227= KEIO University
Japan

229= Indian Institute of Technology KANPUR (i...
India
229= University of ST ANDREWS
United Kingdom

231= Universidad De SANTIAGO De Chile
Chile
231= University of BERGEN
Norway

231= Universität FRANKFURT Am Main
Germany

234= Universiti Sains Malaysia (usm)
Malaysia

234= KOBE University
Japan

236= University of Jyväskylä
Finland

236= FLORIDA STATE University
United States

236= University of ABERDEEN
United Kingdom

239= University of YORK
United Kingdom

239= Technische Universität DARMSTADT
Germany

239= University of COIMBRA
Portugal

242= ARIZONA STATE University
United States

242= University of INDONESIA
INDONESIA




BIDANG STUDI: BIOMEDICINE & LIFE SCIENCES

103 Universitas GADJAH MADA
INDONESIA
104= YONSEI University
Korea, South

104= KOREA University
Korea, South

106 TEL AVIV University
Israel
107= University of BARCELONA
Spain

107= EMORY University
United States

107= University of CALIFORNIA, Irvine
United States

110= University of VIENNA
Austria
110= VU University AMSTERDAM
Netherlands

112 University of OSLO
Norway

113 University of GHENT
Belgium

114= SHANGHAI JIAO TONG University
China
114= Universiti Sains Malaysia (usm)
Malaysia

114= University of WATERLOO
Canada

117 University of BASEL
Switzerland

118 DALHOUSIE University
Canada

119= CARDIFF University
United Kingdom

119= University of CAPE TOWN
South Africa
121 HUMBOLDT University of Berlin
Germany

122 University of ABERDEEN
United Kingdom

123 University of DUNDEE
United Kingdom

124 University of LEEDS
United Kingdom

125 Ecole Normale Superieure, PARIS
France

126 University of INDONESIA
INDONESIA
127 Technical University of MUNICH
Germany

128= TOKYO Institute of Technology
Japan

128= MAASTRICHT University
Netherlands

130= POHANG University of Science And Technol...
Korea, South

130= KEIO University
Japan

132= University of MALAYA (UM)
Malaysia

132= NAGOYA University
Japan

132= ERASMUS University Rotterdam
Netherlands

135= WASEDA University
Japan

135= CASE WESTERN RESERVE University
United States

137 Free University of BERLIN
Germany

138= Federal University of Rio De Janeiro
Brazil
138= University of Göttingen
Germany

138= University of SHEFFIELD
United Kingdom

141 VANDERBILT University
United States

142 University of BOLOGNA
Italy

143 TEXAS A&m University
United States

144= University of GENEVA
Switzerland

144= STOCKHOLM University
Sweden

144= Pontificia Universidad Católica De CHIL...
Chile
147 University of DELHI
India
148= University of PITTSBURGH
United States

148= MACQUARIE University
Australia

150 KOBE University
Japan

151 KYUSHU University
Japan

152= Indian Institute of Technology Delhi (II...
India
152= University of NEWCASTLE
Australia

154= TECHNION - Israel Institute of Technolog...
Israel
154= University of MARYLAND, College Park
United States

154= University of WARWICK
United Kingdom

154= PUSAN National University
Korea, South

158= QUEENSLAND University of Technology
Australia

158= University of ROCHESTER
United States

158= Universidad De SANTIAGO De Chile
Chile
158= University of IOWA
United States

162 GEORGETOWN University
United States

163= ZHEJIANG University
China
163= Umeå University
Sweden

165= INDIANA University Bloomington
United States

165= Université Joseph-fourier, GRENOBLE I
France

167 HOKKAIDO University
Japan

168= University of YORK
United Kingdom

168= University of LIVERPOOL
United Kingdom

168= QUEEN MARY, University of London
United Kingdom

171= University of CALIFORNIA, Santa Cruz
United States

171= University of The PHILIPPINES
Philippines
173= Universität LEIPZIG
Germany

173= TOKYO University of Science (tus)
Japan

175 QUEEN'S University
Canada

176= University Complutense MADRID
Spain

176= OHIO STATE University
United States

178= University of GRONINGEN
Netherlands

178= NEWCASTLE University
United Kingdom

180= BEN GURION University of The Negev
Israel
180= Catholic University of LOUVAIN (UCL)
Belgium

182 University College DUBLIN
Ireland
183 LA TROBE University
Australia

184 University of VIRGINIA
United States

185 National TAIWAN University of Science An...
Taiwan
186 ATENEO De Manila University
Philippines
187 LOMONOSOV MOSCOW State University
Russia
188= SIMON FRASER University
Canada

188= University of SOUTHAMPTON
United Kingdom

188= Technical University of BERLIN
Germany

191= University of PADUA
Italy

191= DARTMOUTH College
United States

191= University of OTTAWA
Canada

194= Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (I...
India
194= University of SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
United States

196 University of Colorado At BOULDER
United States

197 GEORGE WASHINGTON University
United States

198 TUFTS University
United States

199 University of CALIFORNIA, Riverside
United States

200= CHIBA University
Japan

200= University of ARIZONA
United States

200= University of TSUKUBA
Japan

200= Université Du QUéBEC
Canada

204= Aristotle University of THESSALONIKI
Greece
204= University Montpellier 2 - Sciences And ...
France

206 Saint-petersburg State University
Russia
208= STONY BROOK University, State University...
United States

208= Queen's University of BELFAST
United Kingdom

208= CAIRO University
Egypt
211= PENNSYLVANIA STATE University
United States

211= University of FLORIDA
United States

211= TIANJIN University
China
211= Université PARIS V Descartes
France

215 Autonomous University of MADRID
Spain

216= TOHOKU University
Japan

216= University of TURKU
Finland

218= MICHIGAN STATE University
United States

218= LOUGHBOROUGH University
United Kingdom

220= University of CINCINNATI
United States

220= University of LAUSANNE
Switzerland

220= JAWAHARLAL NEHRU University
India
223 BAYLOR University
United States

224= AIRLANGGA University
INDONESIA
224= University of ALABAMA
United States

224= City University of Hong Kong
Hong Kong

227= HANYANG University
Korea, South

227= Universität HAMBURG
Germany

229= University of ST ANDREWS
United Kingdom

229= Sapienza University of Rome
Italy

231= ARIZONA STATE University
United States

231= University of ANTWERP
Belgium

231= SOUTHEAST University
China
235= Rmit University
Australia

235= University of GEORGIA
United States

237= RUTGERS, The State University of New Jer...
United States

237= University of MASSACHUSETTS, Amherst
United States

237= RICE University
United States

237= CHIANG MAI University
Thailand
241= University of CALCUTTA
India
241= Radboud University NIJMEGEN
Netherlands

241= National TSING HUA University
Taiwan
241= FLINDERS University
Australia

245= Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (utm)
Malaysia

245= DURHAM University
United Kingdom

245= Autonomous University of BARCELONA
Spain

245= TONGJI University
China
249 University of PISA
Italy

250= National University of Ireland, GALWAY
Ireland
250= Paris-Sud XI University
France

252= Universidade Estadual PAULISTA
Brazil
252= FLORIDA STATE University
United States

252= National SUN YAT-SEN University
Taiwan
252= Universität Köln(cologne)
Germany

256= NATIONAL CENTRAL University
Taiwan
256= University of BATH
United Kingdom

256= University of BERGEN
Norway

260= University of SUSSEX
United Kingdom

260= Technische Universität DRESDEN
Germany

260= University of CAMPINAS (unicamp)
Brazil
260= CURTIN University of Technology
Australia

264= University of OREGON
United States

264= Vrije Universiteit Brussel (vub)
Belgium

264= WAGENINGEN University
Netherlands

264= BANDUNG Institute of Technology (itb)
INDONESIA

BIDANG STUDI: ART & HUMANITIES

104 University of INDONESIA
INDONESIA
105 TEL AVIV University
Israel
106= University of BIRMINGHAM
United Kingdom

106= University of BARCELONA
Spain

108 YORK University
Canada

109= DURHAM University
United Kingdom

109= GOLDSMITHS, University of London
United Kingdom

111= Universitas GADJAH MADA
INDONESIA

BIDANG STUDI: SOCIAL SCIENCES
102= University of INDONESIA
Indonesia
104 SIMON FRASER University
Canada

105 University of WASHINGTON
United States

106 University of ZURICH
Switzerland

107= University of BERGEN
Norway

107= University of ALBERTA
Canada

109 University of ADELAIDE
Australia

110 YONSEI University
Korea, South

111 OHIO STATE University
United States

112 Soas - School of Oriental And African St...
United Kingdom

113 OSAKA University
Japan

114= DARTMOUTH College
United States

114= California Institute of Technology (calt...
United States

114= STOCKHOLM University
Sweden

114= University Complutense MADRID
Spain

118 Ecole Normale Superieure, PARIS
France

119 University of BIRMINGHAM
United Kingdom

120 University of OTAGO
New Zealand

121 NANJING University
China
122 HEC Paris School of Management
France

123= University of The PHILIPPINES
Philippines
123= City University of Hong Kong
Hong Kong

125 Universität MANNHEIM
Germany

126 MICHIGAN STATE University
United States

127 University of BRISTOL
United Kingdom

128 Universität FRANKFURT Am Main
Germany

129 University of SUSSEX
United Kingdom

130 University of NOTTINGHAM
United Kingdom

131= Free University of Brussels
Belgium

131= University of ST GALLEN (hsg)
Switzerland

133 VU University AMSTERDAM
Netherlands

134 University of MARYLAND, College Park
United States

135 University of CALIFORNIA, Irvine
United States

136 LOMONOSOV MOSCOW State University
Russia
137 University of BARCELONA
Spain

138= University of GRONINGEN
Netherlands

138= ATENEO De Manila University
Philippines
140= PURDUE University
United States

140= University of CAPE TOWN
South Africa
142 Universität Köln(cologne)
Germany

143= Sapienza University of Rome
Italy

143= ETH Zurich (Swiss Federal Institute of T...
Switzerland

143= VICTORIA University of Wellington
New Zealand

143= Autonomous University of MADRID
Spain

147= ESSEC Business School, Paris
France

147= Universitas GADJAH MADA
Indonesia


CATATAN:
1. Hanya ITB, UI dan UGM yang masuk ranking Dunia plus Unair khusus untuk fakultas kedokteran dan ilmu hayati.
2. Untuk “Social Sciences”, ITB tak memiliki fakultas ilmu-ilmu sosial.
2. Untuk “Life Sciences & Biomedicine”, ITB tak memiliki Fakultas Kedokteran, ITB hanya memiliki Sekolah Farmasi dan Sekolah Ilmu Hayati.
3. Untuk “Arts & Humanities”, ITB hanya memiliki Fakultas Seni Rupa dan Desain.
4. Sumber web: www.topuniversities .com


Kesimpulan:
Sebaiknya pemeringkatan PT di dunia dilakukan apple to apple pada bidang studi antar universitas sejenis, begitu pula apple to apple bidang studi antar institut sejenis. Ini pasti akan lebih fair. Inilah yang telah dilakukan oleh majalah “AsiaWeek” (HK) sampai tahun 2000, US News & World Report, BusinessWeek International, Newsweek (USA) sampai sekarang ini. Dan tentu saja oleh para lembaga pemeringkat PT di Amerika Serikat yang sejak awal mempeloporinya sampai sekarang.